RentZen Logo

E. Patrick Shea

Landlord and Tenant Board (LTB) Adjudicator Past Decisions

Overview

Total Orders

145

Orders since 2024

16

Eviction Relief Granted to Tenant since 2024

3

Landlord's Notice Found Invalid since 2024

2

Hearing to Order
22days
Order to Termination
11days

Order Outcomes
PRO

Contested disputes are those where both parties were present at the hearing

PRO
Landlord Wins
30 orders60%
Tenant Wins
30 orders30%
Agreement
30 orders10%

Subscribe to view detailed win rates

Eviction Relief Granted to Tenant 3 Orders since 2024
PRO

627220 Ontario Inc v Shushan

Reason for Relief

Landlord's conduct constituted serious breach of RTA

Who Wins

Agreement

Please subscribe v

Reason for Relief

Please subscribe to pro to view this content.

Who Wins

Landlord

Please subscribe v

Reason for Relief

Please subscribe to pro to view this content.

Who Wins

Tenant

Please subscribe v Please subscribe v Please subscribe v

Reason for Relief

Please subscribe to pro to view this content. Please subscribe to pro to view this content. Please subscribe to pro to view this content.

Who Wins

Tenant

Please subscribe v Please subscribe v

Reason for Relief

Please subscribe to pro to view this content. Please subscribe to pro to view this content.

Who Wins

Landlord
Find More with Pro Search

Unlock Full Access to E. Patrick Shea's Decisions

Get a strategic advantage by understanding how they rule on similar cases.

Gain insights on how E. Patrick Shea typically rules on cases like yours

Access a full decision history to boost your preparation and confidence

Quote past rulings to strengthen your argument

Lanlord's Notice Found Invalid 2 Orders since 2024
PRO

Said v Lyons

Decision Summary

The Tenants are ordered to pay the Landlords $27,511.29 in rent arrears by September 15, 2023, and to pay the full monthly rent on time for 18 months. If the Tenants fail to make any of the required payments, the Landlords may apply to the LTB for an order terminating the tenancy and evicting the Tenants.

Who Wins

Agreement

Please subscribe v

Reason for Relief

Please subscribe to pro to view this content.

Who Wins

Landlord

Please subscribe v

Reason for Relief

Please subscribe to pro to view this content.

Who Wins

Tenant

Please subscribe v Please subscribe v Please subscribe v

Reason for Relief

Please subscribe to pro to view this content. Please subscribe to pro to view this content. Please subscribe to pro to view this content.

Who Wins

Tenant

Please subscribe v Please subscribe v

Reason for Relief

Please subscribe to pro to view this content. Please subscribe to pro to view this content.

Who Wins

Landlord
Find More with Pro Search

Unlock Full Access to E. Patrick Shea's Decisions

Get a strategic advantage by understanding how they rule on similar cases.

Gain insights on how E. Patrick Shea typically rules on cases like yours

Access a full decision history to boost your preparation and confidence

Quote past rulings to strengthen your argument

Contested Dispute by Category
PRO

    • Maintenance Issues8

      Landlord Win Rate: 25%

    • Bad Faith Eviction7

      Landlord Win Rate: 42.86%

    • Illegal Act6

      Landlord Win Rate: 16.67%

    • Persistent Late Payment6

      Landlord Win Rate: 16.67%

    • Property Damage6

      Landlord Win Rate: 33.33%

    • Harassment4

      Landlord Win Rate: 0%

    Unlock Full Access to E. Patrick Shea's Decisions

    Get a strategic advantage by understanding how they rule on similar cases.

    Gain insights on how E. Patrick Shea typically rules on cases like yours

    Access a full decision history to boost your preparation and confidence

    Quote past rulings to strengthen your argument

    Latest Orders

    PRO

    Grewal v Nukkala

    Uncontested Dispute
    March 25, 2025
    York

    LTB issues interim order in Grewal v Nukkala case, directing parties to submit evidence before hearing on tenant allegations of illegal entry, interference, and harassment.

    ContentionModerate
    0
    0
    Read more

    Oz v Shearer

    Contested Dispute
    Landlord Wins
    December 20, 2024
    Sunderland

    Landlords granted eviction order against Tenants and Unauthorized Occupants in Sunderland rental dispute.

    Eviction Relief Granted
    ContentionHigh
    0
    0
    Read more

    Amiraco Properties Inc. v Corra

    Contested Dispute
    Agreement
    November 1, 2024
    Windsor
    Review Order

    LTB review order in Windsor non-payment case involving tenant's consumer proposal, results in negotiated payment plan.

    ContentionLow
    0
    0
    Read more

    Limbada et al v 2491364 Ontario Inc

    Contested Dispute
    Agreement
    October 9, 2024
    Toronto

    LTB orders Toronto landlord to address maintenance issues, provide disclosure in interim order for 1440 and 1442 Lawrence Ave W tenants.

    Section 82 Issues Raised and Permitted
    ContentionHigh
    3
    0
    Read more

    Wakunick-Fleury et al. v Star Towers Ltd et al.

    Contested Dispute
    Tenant Wins
    September 17, 2024
    Welland

    LTB holds landlord and shareholders personally liable for disregarding tenant rights and ignoring orders in Welland rental dispute.

    Landlord Aggravating Factor
    Landlord Sent Invalid Notice
    ContentionExtreme
    0
    0
    Read more

    Vasdani v Aharon

    Contested Dispute
    Tenant Wins
    September 12, 2024
    Toronto

    Landlord and purchaser ordered to pay tenant $4,903 for bad faith eviction using N12 notice.

    ContentionExtreme
    0
    0
    Read more

    Unlock Full Access to E. Patrick Shea's Decisions

    Get a strategic advantage by understanding how they rule on similar cases.

    Gain insights on how E. Patrick Shea typically rules on cases like yours

    Access a full decision history to boost your preparation and confidence

    Quote past rulings to strengthen your argument

    Latest Insights from Our Blog

    Stay informed with expert analysis on rental law, tenant rights, and LTB decisions

    Bad Faith N12 Evictions: When Landlords Abuse Personal Use Notices in Ontario
    Jan 6, 2025 · RentZen

    Bad Faith N12 Evictions: When Landlords Abuse Personal Use Notices in Ontario

    An analysis of bad faith N12 eviction cases reveals how landlords exploit personal use notices to circumvent rent control, the warning signs tenants should watch for, and the substantial financial penalties that follow.

    Read more →
    The N11 Agreement Trap: When 'Mutual' Terminations Aren't Really Mutual in Ontario
    Jan 10, 2025 · RentZen

    The N11 Agreement Trap: When 'Mutual' Terminations Aren't Really Mutual in Ontario

    Exploring how N11 agreements are often signed under duress or misunderstanding, leading to disputes about whether terminations were truly voluntary and the legal standards for challenging these agreements.

    Read more →
    The N8 Notice Deep Dive: Persistent Late Payment and How It Differs from Non-Payment Cases in Ontario
    Jan 10, 2025 · RentZen

    The N8 Notice Deep Dive: Persistent Late Payment and How It Differs from Non-Payment Cases in Ontario

    Understanding the critical differences between N4 and N8 notices, common pitfalls that invalidate N8 notices, and the unique legal standards for persistent late payment cases.

    Read more →

    Need Legal Help? We've Got You Covered

    Whether you need to find qualified legal professionals or post your specific legal needs to get competitive quotes, our platform connects you with the right help.

    Find Legal Professionals

    Browse our directory of verified paralegals and lawyers specializing in Ontario rental law and LTB matters.

    Browse Professionals

    Post Your Legal Needs

    Describe your legal situation and receive competitive quotes from qualified professionals in our marketplace.

    Post a Bounty

    Join thousands of Ontarians who have found legal help through our platform

    Get Started - Post Your CaseBrowse Professionals
    View All Articles